All About Daily Kansas City News

Repair Or Replace Your Roof? Here's how to decide

Nov 23

Re-roofing vs. Roof Replacement

Many homeowners confuse roof replacement with roofing re-roofing. These are home repairs that repair the roofing structure and replace damaged shingles. They are quite different.

It is almost always necessary to replace a roof for mold growth, water damage, missing or damaged shingles, or decking under the roof.

Re-roofing can be the most cost-effective and attractive way to improve your roof's appearance.

How do you decide whether to replace or repair your roof

It is important to plan ahead for major home renovations like painting or replacing your roof.

Broken shingles can cause more damage than it is worth.

Roof spots discolored due to age

Roofs are durable and can last a lifetime. Asphalt roofing can last up to 20 years.

Clay roof tiles and metal roofing materials can wear faster than clay roof tiles. Often, it is a better decision to replace the entire roof rather than make repairs on a frequent basis.

Find out more about roofing materials, their lifespans, and more in our articles

Roof Condition

The next step is to evaluate the state of your roof. If a tree falls onto your roof, this could cause large holes that can't be repaired.

It may be possible to repair minor or major damage to your roof. This is the best option.

Roof: Affected Area

You can also identify the area affected to determine if your roof needs to be replaced or repaired. A small hole could be found in your bedroom or dining room.

Small amounts of damage can often be repaired and the roof won't need to be replaced. Replacing the entire roof may be a better choice.

How long do you intend to stay in your home before selling it?

Many homeowners decide to renovate their homes to increase their home's value. If you have specific problems with your roof, you may need to immediately replace it.

If you're moving to a new area, it is likely that you will need to relocate. Depending on the size of your project, it can take up to three to five days to complete your roof. can replace most roofs within one day. Hercules Roofing can complete most roof replacements in one day. However, you can submit claims, get permits, and obtain other approvals that may take between 20 to 30 days.

Roof Replacement Drawbacks and Benefits

Roof repairs can sometimes be a bad choice. These are the advantages and disadvantages of roof repairs.


Roof repairs tend to be less expensive.

Car repairs take very little time.

They can extend the life expectancy of your roof.


  • Sometimes it can be hard to match the colors of shingles in a replacement project.

  • Bad workmanship and patching can cause even more problems.

  • It can mask underlying problems.

Roof Replacement Drawbacks Benefits

Roof replacements are more costly than roof repairs.


  • It is able to fix any roofing problem, even ones hidden under tiles.

  • A new roof could save you money over the long term.

  • This can improve curb appeal.

  • It improves energy efficiency and lowers utility costs.

  • Roof replacements last longer than repairs.


  • It will take longer to renovate the entire roof.

  • This project is more expensive.

  • It takes longer to replace a roof than to repair it.